The Loud Silence


The Loud Silence

Tacit agreement: Leaders spend a lot of time crafting responses but little time appreciating the interpretation of silence.

Silence surrenders control and allows others to establish meaning.

Why might you choose not to voice an opinion?

  • You're still processing.
  • You agree.
  • You haven't formulated a thoughtful response.
  • You're not invested in the outcome.
  • You fear the repercussions of speaking up.

All legitimate reasons.

But here's the problem. Others don't know why you're silent. They assign their own meaning.

Often, that meaning represents agreement.

The higher your authority, the louder your silence.

Think about a company-wide announcement. The CEO delivers the message while the executive team stands quietly alongside. No one else says a word, yet their presence communicates support and alignment.

We recognize this dynamic in big moments. But what about the small ones?

A decision you question but don't challenge.

A behavior you witness but don't address.

An idea you disagree with but don't contest.

Your silence may be interpreted as approval, indifference, or permission.

And those assumptions can create disconnect, resentment, and unintended consequences.

So what can you do?

We often believe we need a well-crafted response, complete with justification, before speaking up.

I'd challenge that assumption.

Sometimes all that's needed is an acknowledgment:

  • "Something about this isn't sitting right with me. I need more time to think it through."
  • "My initial reaction is to disagree, but I'm open to understanding more."
  • "This deserves more discussion. Can we find time to explore it further?"

None of these require certainty. But each communicates something important: I'm engaged, I'm thinking, and my silence should not be mistaken for agreement.

Leadership requires intentionality and courage. Not always the courage to have the answer, but sometimes simply the courage to speak before you do.

Where might your silence be communicating something you never intended to say?

Weekly Wisdom

Great leadership is rarely taught, but it can be mastered. I break down complex topics and offer insights, resources, and challenges to help you strengthen your skills, build confidence, refine your mindset, and lead high-performing teams.

Read more from Weekly Wisdom

What if Nobody Likes it? Here goes nothing. I talk a lot about leading with your heart, trusting your internal worth, and shedding the mind games we play to reveal a more authentic version of ourselves. Easier said than done. I know! Well, here I am. On full display. An unimaginable loss of a child has become a legacy of hope and love for others. Max left us far too early, but his love of art lives on through scholarships supporting young artists. Make It for Max is an annual fundraiser...

Are You a Quitter? I woke up to a Focus Five email from Dave Stachowiak. His message resonated, particularly this one: Know When to Quit. I want you to take this in. It's important. In the podcast episode, How to Quit Bad Stuff Faster, Dave talks with Annie Duke, a former professional poker player, about the importance of knowing when to let go and change course. It got me thinking. According to Annie Duke, there's a striking difference between professional and amateur poker players:...

Reader, just because you can, should you? Many coaching conversations begin with a focused challenge. As if there is a magic wand that needs a quick spin and then everything will be right again. Unfortunately, this is not how it works. More often than not, I will redirect and ask for introspection. The challenge you bring to the conversation is usually a symptom. It is the accumulation of stories you have told yourself, conversations you have avoided, expectations you have accepted, and...